Well Water Softeners
Hard well water leaves white scale on fixtures, in the water heater and on every glass. A softener removes the hardness, and it can take clear-water iron up to 3 ppm; above that, put an iron filter ahead of it. Our 7500 ceramic-disc and 5900-BT Bluetooth softeners run 16K to 96K grain (nominal), with sizing, flow ratings and salt use below.
Which Well Water Softener to Choose?
Both use the same resin: ResinTech CG10, 10% crosslink, made in the USA. The difference is the control valve on top.
Which setup does your well water need?
| Your water test shows | What to install |
|---|---|
| Hardness, and you want to get rid of white spots and scale and protect your fixtures and appliances | A water softener. It removes the hardness and stops scale from building up in your water heater, fixtures and appliances. |
| Hardness, and you don't want salt | A Scale Stop no-salt conditioner. It protects pipes, fixtures and appliances from scale buildup. It doesn't remove hardness, so above about 5 grains per gallon (gpg) you'll still see spots on glass. Above 15 gpg, we recommend a water softener. |
| pH under 6.8 | An acid neutralizer, ahead of everything else |
| pH 6.8 to 7 | It depends on your hardness and alkalinity. With low hardness and alkalinity the water is corrosive and needs a neutralizer. With enough of both, it may not. Test pH, hardness and alkalinity, and we'll check it for you. |
| pH 7 or higher and scale-forming (LSI above +0.5) | No neutralizer. A softener or scale control handles it. |
| Hardness plus clear-water iron up to 3 ppm, pH 7 or below | An iron filter ahead of the softener is the better fix. A softener alone can handle it, but it regenerates more often and uses more salt. |
| Iron over 3 ppm, or water that comes out of the well orange or cloudy | An iron filter ahead of the softener |
| Hardness plus arsenic | A MetSorb arsenic filter before the softener, never after it |
| Hardness plus PFAS | The softener, then a PFAS system after it |
Install order on a well:
- pressure tank
- sand separator (if you have sand)
- neutralizer
- iron filter
- arsenic filter
- softener
- PFAS system
- UV
- water heater
Skip what your water doesn't need, but keep the order.
When you need an iron filter
A softener isn't our usual answer for iron (the limits are in the FAQ below). When you need an iron filter, size it to your iron:
| Iron (ppm) | Iron filter |
|---|---|
| up to 5 | Pro-OX Lite or Pro-OX |
| up to 8 | Pro-OX AIR |
| up to 10 | Pro-OX Ozone |
| over 10 | A custom system designed from your water test |
AIR and Ozone oxidize the iron; the Pro-OX media then filters it out. At pH 6.8 to under 7.0, Pro-OX works better with AIR or chlorine ahead.
Sizing a softener for well water
Test your water for hardness, iron and pH, plus TDS and alkalinity if you want us to check whether it's corrosive. Start with our well water test kits.
Pick the grain size. Grains needed = your hardness in gpg (add 4 gpg for each 1 ppm of clear-water iron) × gallons a day (75 per person) × days between regenerations (7 is typical). Softener resin holds about 30,000 grains per cubic foot at full salt (15 lb per cu ft). The 32K, 48K and 64K in our model names are nominal ratings. Example: 2 bathrooms, 4 people, 15 gpg: 15 × 300 gallons × 7 days = 31,500 grains, so a 1.5 cu ft (48K) softener. Above 75 gpg (hardness plus iron), size up or regenerate more often. The softener sizing calculator does the math.
Check the flow. Your peak flow is about 2 gallons per minute plus 2 more per bathroom (6 gallons per minute for a 2-bath home). Pick a size whose peak flow rate covers that. At peak flow, expect about a 15 psi pressure drop; at normal household use it's less.
| Size | Peak flow rate (gallons per minute) | |
|---|---|---|
| 7500 | 5900-BT | |
| 16K (6x35) | 5 | 5 |
| 24K (8x44) | 7.5 | 7.5 |
| 32K (9x48) | 16 | 16 |
| 32K (13x30 short) | 10 | 10 |
| 48K (10x54) | 18 | 18 |
| 64K (12x52) | 20 | 20 |
| 80K (13x54) | 25 | 21 |
| 96K (14x65) | 30 | 21 |
These softeners run at 30–90 psi and 41–100°F.
Salt use and what drives cost
Salt: the 1.5 cu ft softener in the example above uses about 68 lb of salt a month (1.7 forty-pound bags) at full salt, regenerating every 10 days. At the efficient setting (6 lb per cu ft) it uses about 41 lb (1 bag) and regenerates about every 7 days. Clear-water iron raises both: it counts as extra hardness and needs more frequent regeneration.
Cost depends on three things:
- the grain size your hardness and household need
- the valve (7500 or 5900-BT)
- whether your well also needs a neutralizer, iron filter or arsenic filter ahead of the softener
Frequently Asked Questions
Yes, with limits. A softener only handles clear-water iron: iron that's dissolved, so the water runs clear from the tap and turns orange after it sits. That usually means a pH of 7 or below. Up to 3 ppm, a softener can take it. Above 3 ppm, or if the water comes out of the well already orange or cloudy, put an iron filter ahead of the softener.
The trade-off is salt. Iron that sits in the resin soaks in and fouls it, so the softener has to regenerate more often than it would for hardness alone. That means more salt and more water. When you size it, count each 1 ppm of iron as about 4 grains of hardness. At 15 gpg, 2 ppm of iron adds 8 gpg, about 50% more salt.
If iron is your main problem rather than hardness, an iron filter is the better fix.
Often the softener is the same: we sell the 7500 ceramic disc and 5900-BT softeners for both. What changes is what goes ahead of it. On a private well, test for pH, iron and arsenic, which may need their own filter ahead of the softener. On city water, a carbon filter for chlorine usually goes with the softener.
The MetSorb arsenic filter goes before the softener, never after it.
Last: after the softener and before the water heater.
30–90 psi and 41–100°F.
Yes. Plan on 4 to 6 hours, longer if you have a lot of plumbing to change.
A softener removes the hardness (calcium and magnesium) from the water. A Scale Stop no-salt conditioner prevents scale but leaves the hardness reading where it was.
With regular regeneration, softener resin lasts 10 years or more. Ours is 10% crosslink resin, which holds up to chlorine if you chlorinate your well.
Water softeners use a special type of inert resin that selectively removes dissolved positively charged particles, known as ions (in this case calcium and magnesium ions) from water in a process known as ion-exchange. For every ion of calcium that the resin removes, it adds an ion of sodium, or potassium if you use potassium salt. Since sodium or potassium does not form scale or deposits the way calcium hardness does, the water is then considered "soft".
No. Salt in of itself does not make the water soft. Removing calcium and magnesium and other "hardness minerals" from water is what makes the water soft.
No. The Water Quality Association rates hardness in grains per gallon (gpg) as calcium carbonate: under 3.5 gpg is soft to slightly hard, 3.5–7 moderately hard, 7–10.5 hard, and over 10.5 very hard. If you're on a private well or spring, test your water. White spots and scale on fixtures and appliances usually mean hard water.
No. A balanced diet of calcium-rich foods such as vegetables, meat, soy or dairy products are better sources of calcium.
For most people, no. A softener adds about 8 mg of sodium per liter for each grain per gallon of hardness it removes (Virginia Cooperative Extension BSE-255). At 20 gpg that's about 160 mg per liter, so you'd drink about 4 gallons of softened water to reach the 2,300 mg Daily Value. If you're on a low-sodium diet, EPA guidance is no more than 20 mg/L of sodium in drinking water: drink from a reverse-osmosis tap, or leave the kitchen cold line unsoftened.
Yes and No. Many softened waters are fine for drinking, but it depends on the total dissolved solids and any additives such as chlorine, or contaminants such as nitrate or metals. Soft water removes calcium & hardness minerals only. In most of the areas we serve, the total dissolved solids are high enough that many of our clients use reverse-osmosis systems to purify the water at one tap for drinking and purified ice etc. They continue drinking the water occasionally from other areas of the house.
No, this has proven to be false. The confusion arises because many naturally soft waters are also low in pH (acidic) and are naturally corrosive. Softened water actually has a slightly higher pH than un-softened water. Calcium buildup can cause corrosion sites to develop in piping systems and soft water may actually help to prevent corrosion in some cases.
After the calcium is removed the water will feel more slippery, but this does not make your skin dry. Most people will report that after showering in soft water their skin and hair feels softer and less dry.
The softeners we have can be adjusted so that a little hard water is blended back into the soft water. This makes the water softer but not zero soft so it eliminates the problem of the slippery feeling. Our systems come with by-pass mixing valve that allows one to blend in some hard water.
Yes. Soft water lathers with less soap. Learn more about the benefits of soft water.
None of these devices physically remove calcium hardness from water. Instead, the water is treated so it won't form scale in pipes and on fixtures or appliances such as water heaters. Salt-free conditioner makers rate them up to about 50 gpg, but that rating means they keep scale from forming in the pipes. Above about 5 gpg you'll still see spots on glass, and above 15 gpg we recommend a softener. TAC conditioners are no-salt systems. Read more about them here
Request a Call






